conley6.gif (2529 bytes)


Comfort food nation
Sit back with a bowl of mac ’n cheese, a piled-high burger or cup of piping hot chili at some of the area’s coziest eateries

By MARTIN HINTZ

November 2007


Meatloaf at Caquette Cafe


Arriving at what constitutes the perfect comfort food is a formidable task. After all, one person’s bacon-lettuce-tomato is another’s raw fish eyeballs.

Whatever the dish, however, there is general consensus among both epicures and 6-year-old kids that such food must be simple to make and be filling.

Being inexpensive is the final ingredient in any comfort food recipe.

The mere thought of comfort food must also be emotionally satisfying. Witness French author Marcel Proust, who hearkened back to a loving childhood when his memory was primed by the scent of madeleines, those Gallic cake-like, shell-shaped cookies.

"Comfort foods are usually considered those we grew up with, giving us fond childhood memories," says John Reiss, chef instructor in the culinary arts program at the Milwaukee Area Technical College and a 20-year teaching veteran. "These foods, like meatloaf, usually don’t involve complicated recipes." Personally, Reiss is a roasted chicken aficionado, preferring a flavorful organic bird that he merely rubs with olive oil, adding a bit of salt and pepper and then sticking it on a backyard grill for about two hours. "It’s finger-licking good for leftovers, too," he offers.

An item becomes an "official" comfort food as it evolves into a traditional dish, whether the iconic Thanksgiving turkey or Easter ham. Firefighters, known for their culinary abilities, have been preparing homemade pizza every Saturday in their station houses for years, according to Milwaukee Fire Chief Doug Holton. "They really look forward to that every weekend," he says. "It’s become their comfort food."

High-end comforts

When dining out, Reiss enjoys said meatloaf at Coquette Café in the Third Ward. This isn’t your grandma’s Sunday preparation, but bacon-wrapped and made with Strauss veal, served with garlic mashed potatoes and a mushroom reduction. Reiss also goes for macaroni complemented with fresh goat cheese roux and rosemary-roasted chicken, as served as the signature dish at The Social in the Fifth Ward.

Chicken Fried chicken at Maxie's Southern Comfort


Milwaukee is happily dealing with a surge of such high-end eateries. Many offer what can be construed as upscale comfort food, but comfort food nonetheless, albeit perhaps served on good china.

Now think potatoes. The pomme frites served on the side or as a party hors d’oeuvre, as well as light and fluffy puréed potatoes, created by Adam Siegel, executive chef of Bartolotta’s Lake Park Bistro, are amazing. Even grandma would approve of the latter ... sans lumps in the spuds. Chez Jacques’s chef Michel also makes dynamite "real" french fries, as well, served with steak.

Burger bests

There are some foods that are always on the comfort list, with hamburgers, of course, among the all-time winners. For Steve Remmel, operations manager for the George Webb Corp., a traditional burger simply garnished with lettuce, tomato, mustard and ketchup is pure bliss. But he adds cheese, always cheese. "After all, this is Wisconsin," he confirms.

Since the 1940s, the standard George Webb diner has remained Milwaukee’s classic 24/7 comfort food palace. The restaurants, in 41 locations, seem timeless. The company annually serves a half-million pounds of USDA choice ground beef and 100,000 pounds of American and Swiss cheeses.

Remmel’s mom, Jean, used to own a diner and was a burger flipping pro, as well as getting up at 3:30 a.m. to bake her own bread. "Now that was comfort food," fondly recalls her son.

Sometimes, Remmel will do a double or triple patty, "depending on how much comfort I need," he chuckles. "That’s what George wanted from the beginning: wholesome food like chili, hash browns, wheat cakes. Foods that were tasty and filling.

Real chili


"And, best of all, it’s comforting that you don’t have to do the dishes."

These days, some of the trendies go for miniaturized burgers or those dandified with exotic cheeses, mushrooms, red onions, salsa and jalapenos.

But a burger needs to stand alone on judgment day, when teeth meets meat. Subsequently, Milwaukee burger fans argue for hours about their favorite drive-ins, whether favoring the patties at Gilles Frozen Custard or the Wisconsin-based Culver’s with its signature ButterBurger. Both the platter-sized presentations at Kopp’s and White Castle sliders also have adherents.

Burgers at Solly’s Grille, the North Shore Bistro, Ted’s Ice Cream, Elsa’s on the Park, Derry Hegarty’s and numerous other joints also jostle for the hamburger crown. Sobelman’s, hidden deep in the Menomonee Valley factory district, is admittedly among the hierarchy with its one-third pound of Black Angus beef fried to perfection. As Popeye’s burger-mania friend Wimpy could assert, "Gotta luv ’em all."

Chicken and cheese please

For grilled cheese, another comfort staple, there is no better place to go other than to the Wisconsin food products building at the Wisconsin State Fair. Savvy eaters get three for $5 with a coupon from the back of the fair program, dished up by the fair’s Dairy Promotion Board. According to Patrice Harris, the fair’s communications director (and a secret State Fair buffalo burrito fan), 55,000 of the sandwiches were served this year.

Chicken is another all-time favorite. Greater Milwaukee fowl fanciers head to Maxie’s Southern Comfort, which offers mouth-watering choices of grilled, barbecued, fried or blackened birds, as well as in po-boys or smothered. Chicken Fried Tuesdays have become a popular promo, says Maxie’s manager Sal Anschuetz. Executive chef Joe Muench, formerly of Eddie Martini’s, also has a Chicken Fried Chicken with Southern style tasso gravy, a highly seasoned sauce with elements of pork, bacon, garlic and loads of herbs.

Soul foods

For comfort with soul, the Perkins Family Restaurant has been dishing out helpings of down-home, secret recipe goodies for nearly four decades.

Catfish (fried or grilled to order) is the most popular menu item, followed by baked chicken and dressing. Longtime staples remain sides of black-eyed peas, sweet potatoes, collard greens and cornbread, followed by peach cobbler or coconut pineapple cake. Hilda Perkins, who founded the restaurant with her late husband, Will Sr., still drops by daily to check on son Will Jr., and his wife, Cherry, who now run the establishment. "She wants to be sure it’s done right," asserts the younger Perkins.

Duels could be fought over the city’s best barbecue title, yet Speed Queen Bar-B-Q is always a taste-test finalist. This pick-up-and-go place is home to Milwaukee’s most famous barbecue sandwiches. Ribs ’n sauce also rule at Saz’s, Lake City, Pitch’s, Brew City and other notables where a bibbed and 10-napkin dinner is standard.

Real Chili, celebrating its 75th anniversary this year, is another local favorite. Packed with spaghetti and beans, or dazzled up with cheese and onions, a husky bowl of chili makes life worth living. Several visiting Las Vegas show girls, performing in a Mardi Gras revue at Potawatomi Bingo Casino during this past winter’s coldest days, made a point of hanging out between shows at the Real Chili on East Wells Street. They were grateful to put aside their feathers for a bit and warm up with Milwaukee’s finest.

And don’t miss the Sunday night buffet at Potawatomi Bingo Casino. "Sunday Supper" gives you a taste of authentic Southern delicacies, such as spicy glazed barbecue pork ribs, Southern fried chicken and Chef Monroe’s famous cornmeal breaded catfish. Of course, Dream Dance’s Amish Chicken and Slow Braised B.B.Q. Pork hanker to those in need of comfort, as well.

To warm your soul on the Northshore, try Libby Montana’s Cooky’s Meatloaf or the restaurant’s famous Pot Pie, a rotating special with a new tummy-filling flavor each week.

Ethnic eats

Eating such comfort foods are the edible cushions to fall back on during stressful times. Since he’s on the road so much, Milwaukee Brewers’ General Manager Doug Melvin appreciates anything home cooked but Hispanic food constitutes a home run for him. Melvin went the gamut during this year’s hectic National League Central race, chowing down tacos, enchiladas, quesadillas and other lip-smacking South-of-the-Border wonders.

The smart Mexican food fan will find such goodies and a lot more temptations at the nonpretentious but always satisfying Mercado El Rey lunch counter.

"Hearty" and "soul-satisfying" are two adjectives best describing the small dining area in the South Side store, a community hub. Among the regulars is Rico Castillo, a local restaurant manager and chef, who — knowing both quality and comfort — eats there two to three times a week when off duty.

A good chef understands his customers and caters to their culinary wishes.

Subsequently, Jack McNeir, the Italian Community Center’s executive chef, knows his gnocchi. "Pasta and risotto are among our most popular menu items," he points out, adding that any meal with veal, particularly a scaloppini, earns delighted murmurs from visiting mommas and the papas.

It’s obvious that McNeir’s Scots-Irish background hasn’t prevented him from accommodating an Italian clientele that demands a lot from a rigatoni. Yet when pressed, McNeir admits to being a stew guy. Hefty servings of his mom’s hearty concoctions, made either with lamb or beef, helped him make it through Wisconsin’s winters as a youngster.

Marvelously delicious handmade beef sausages called chevapchichi or burek, whether beef, cheese or spinach, are best served at Branko Radicevic’s Three Brothers Bar & Restaurant near the lake. For comfort food must be unhurriedly eaten with friends seated around one of the old tables, secreted in a lamp-lit corner at this South Side restaurant. Don’t forget the slivovitz, Serbian plum brandy, as a soothing digestif. This is the slow food movement at its best where comfort means ambiance, too.

In the heat of battle, Shakespeare’s Richard III cried out, "Chocolate pudding, chocolate pudding, my kingdom for chocolate pudding." Or was he calling for fried rice, shish kebob, chicken subgum, hopple-popple, spanakopita, reuben, kielbasa or kimchi. He certainly wasn’t hollering for a low-calorie plate. Mom wouldn’t have it any other way.