The reason New Berlin, Waukesha and other
communities in the western part of the Milwaukee region can’t use Lake
Michigan water is because the state of Michigan is hogging all of it.
Michigan is leading the opposition to proposals to allow some local
communities to use Lake Michigan water, but the biggest single user of
Great Lakes water is Michigan itself.
New Berlin, Waukesha and others would love to get Lake Michigan water
because many of the wells in those communities have tested high for
radium levels. Cleaning them up is very expensive. There’s a problem.
The Sunnyslope hill (about 14000 West) is the dividing line of the Great
Lakes basin. Groundwater to the east of the hill has Lake Michigan as
its source but not the water on the west side of the hill. That’s
critical because a treaty signed by the United States and Canada limits
water use to the basin.
But that standard is rigged to favor Michigan. The ENTIRE STATE is in
the basin! Lansing, Mich., in the middle of the state and 125 miles from
the nearest Great Lake, is allowed to tap water from the lakes system,
but New Berlin, 15 miles from Lake Michigan, cannot. It’s an absurd
standard. Even Upper Michigan is entirely within the Great Lakes basin.
The reasons for this have to do with the topography of the area and
the elevation below sea level. But the "Basin Standard" is a
ridiculous way of deciding who can use the water. States like Wisconsin
and Illinois, which spend a fortune on the Great Lakes, get far less
water than Michigan solely because of Michigan’s sea level and
drainage patterns. If Michigan wants to monopolize all the water, it
should have to pay more to care for the water.
It is likely that Gov. Doyle and the Wisconsin Department of Natural
Resources will back New Berlin’s request because they realize how
badly Wisconsin is being shafted in the water wars. The ultimate
decision will be made by federal courts. In the meantime, New Berlin
residents are stuck with the irony that while many of them can’t use
lake Michigan water, all of them are compelled (because of forced
membership in the Milwaukee sewer district) to send all of their water
back to Lake Michigan.
A far more reasonable standard would be to base a state’s ability
to use Great Lakes water on the amount of shoreline it has on one of the
lakes. This would still give Michigan the most water of all (because
Lakes Huron, Superior and Michigan all border it). Unfortunately,
Wisconsin’s two U.S. senators, Herb Kohl and Russ Feingold, have
virtually no clout, and getting a more reasonable standard is likely to
be politically impossible.
***
Communities all over the region are on a fee binge. In an attempt to
make their property taxes appear to be artificially low, they are
imposing mandatory fees on the same property owners. Menomonee Falls,
for example, just imposed a staggering $85 garbage fee. In addition to
allowing local bureaucrats to play shell games by collecting taxes
without calling them taxes, the fees have the effect of shifting a
greater portion of the tax burden to owners of less expensive
properties. In Menomonee Falls, for example, by taking garbage service
off of property taxes and switched to a flat fee, the owner of $750,000
home will pay the same amount as the owner of a $130,000 bungalow.
***
Don’t be surprised if some state Assembly Republicans break party
ranks and align themselves with Gov. Doyle when he goes on his own tax
and fee binge in 2007. They’ll be auditioning for state jobs. Now that
Republicans hold only a 52-47 Assembly edge, Doyle will likely steal a
page from Tommy Thompson’s playbook and start appointing Republican
members to state jobs. If only three of these Republicans quit their
legislative posts and are replaced by Democrats in special elections,
the Democrats will take control of the Assembly (they already have the
state Senate).
Neenah’s Dean Kaufert, a Republican, is almost certain to be given
a top Doyle job within a few weeks. His district is one with a lot of
Democratic voters. (It makes no sense for Doyle to appoint a legislator
from a district the Republicans are likely to hold in a new election.)
Another trick up the Doyle sleeve will be to convince a big-money
special interest to offer a high-paying job to one of these Republicans
on the condition the Assembly seat is given up. I’m sure Doyle’s
ever-generous Potawatomi friends could always use another lobbyist.
Thompson did this a couple of times with Democratic members of the
state Senate. If Doyle is able to pull it off, it will mean both houses
of the Legislature will be in his pocket and he will be able to pass
literally any bill he wants.
Shudders.
***
Prediction: University of Wisconsin-Whitewater will upset perennial
winner Mount Union on Saturday for the Division III college football
championship, sending Coach Bob Berezowitz out in Al McGuire style by
winning a national title in his final game.
(Mark Belling is the host of a daily WISN radio talk show and a
Sunday television show. His column runs Wednesdays in The Freeman.)