What was Rembert Weakland thinking?
* * *
The Milwaukee Roman Catholic Archdiocese is in a mess. It is facing
millions of dollars worth of fiscal cuts because of damages being paid
to victims of sexual abuse by priests. Worse, the church is in danger of
losing its single-most important asset, its standing as a moral leader,
because of revelations about its enabling of pedophile priests.
The latest round of news was especially bad. Documents from a
California lawsuit chronicled the church’s disgraceful handling of
ex-priest Franklyn Becker, who was shuttled around by Milwaukee
officials despite numerous reports of inappropriate conduct with young
boys. But there are court documents and pending lawsuits in several
other cases. If those records are as damaging as the documents from the
Becker case, the church’s disgrace will be compounded.
In short, the Milwaukee Archdiocese has been exposed for repeatedly
allowing dangerous men to have access to impressionable children and for
refusing to do anything about them after being caught.
* * *
But, it wasn’t the "church" that did all of this. The
Milwaukee Archdiocese was run by Rembert Weakland when the priestly
misconduct was occurring. The former archbishop was the one shuttling
the clerical creeps from church to church and covering up their criminal
and sinful conduct. Again, what was Weakland thinking?
The best way to answer the question is to look at Weakland’s own
words. Several years ago he famously commented on abuse cases by saying
many young boys attempt to "seduce" priests. He later denied
that he meant this as a rationalization of the behavior but the comment
is a window into Weakland’s state of mind. Given his own dalliance
with a young man, it’s apparent Weakland empathized with priests who
were faced with terrible temptations.
Weakland’s reaction was despicable. Whether he’s an archbishop or
a fast food manager, a person who is aware that adults under his
supervision are taking indecent liberties with children has a legal and
moral obligation to do something about it. Weakland should have
contacted the authorities and done everything in his power to remove
these abusers from the priesthood.
* * *
Timothy Dolan, Weakland’s successor, is a remarkable man. He exudes
holiness. He is a commanding moral leader and an undeniably spiritual
man. He’s the one who is left to clean up the Weakland mess. He’s
trying to sell the Cousins Center to raise money and is being forced to
look at serious operational cuts. But he must take another step to
restore the thing even more important than the archdiocesan finances. He
needs to restore its moral authority.
Dolan needs to publicly disassociate the Milwaukee church from
Weakland. He can start by taking Weakland’s name off the church
buildings currently defiled with it. He must then condemn Weakland’s
unholy and legally liable actions. This isn’t time for one bishop to
stick up for another. Dolan must do what Weakland wouldn’t - the right
thing.
* * *
There’s a lot of chutzpah and gall in our society but for an
example of real hypocrisy we need only look at a small bar and
restaurant in the town of Genesee named Saxe’s.
The owner, Tom Saxe, is currently featured in an ad campaign telling
his "nonsmoking" story. Saxe describes his own bout with
cancer, something he attributes to his years behind the bar having smoke
blown in his face and down his lungs. He goes on to say he "cares
very deeply" about his employees and won’t let them be subjected
to the hideous secondhand smoke that made him gravely ill.
It’s all very touching until you learn that Tom Saxe’s restaurant
ALLOWS smoking. Like most other places, you can’t smoke in the dining
room but are allowed to puff away at the bar, presumably blowing smoke
in the faces and down the lungs of the employees Saxe claims to
"care deeply about." When I asked Saxe about this astonishing
contradiction between words and actions, he told me he hasn’t banned
smoking because he thinks it would cost him business.
Saxe is pushing for a statewide ban on smoking in all bars and
restaurants. But he could ban smoking right now without any change in
law. In fact, a growing number of local restaurants have already gone
smoke-free in response to customer demand. But instead of featuring the
operators of joints that are actually smoke-free, the group called
"Smoke-Free Wisconsin" is using in its ads a guy who allows
smoking.
When I asked Saxe why he doesn’t join the others and ban smoking,
he says it’ll happen soon. After he calls a press conference, he says.
This guy belongs in the Sanctimony Hall of Fame. One other thing. Saxe,
who claims he got cancer from his years inhaling secondhand cigarette
smoke, is a former firefighter.
(Mark Belling is the host of a daily WISN radio talk show. His
column runs Wednesdays in The Freeman.)