From
the moment the Selected by God choir — famed for the
"Imported from Detroit" commercial — sang
"Lean on Me" at the ribbon-cutting ceremony,
the 2012 North American International Auto Show has hit
one high note after another.
For
heaven’s sake, Detroit just hosted the operatic
grandeur of the unveiling of Germany’s two greatest
sports cars — the Mercedes-Benz SL 550 and Porsche 911
Carrera convertible.
Not
every vehicle at Cobo Center was on time and on key,
though.
Here
are my choices for who made beautiful music and which
automakers missed a beat.
HIT:
2013 Ford Fusion: With arresting looks, advanced
technology and startling fuel economy, the Fusion will
be among the cars to beat for every major award this
year.
Its
voracious grille and sleek fastback tail take midsize
sedans to new heights of style.
A
plug-in hybrid that promises an EPA rating above 100 mpg
in battery mode, a conventional hybrid that gets 47 mpg
in the city and a gasoline-powered model rated 37 mpg on
the highway add practicality.
Ford’s
usual suite of advanced features completes the picture,
including what should be an improved version of the
controversial MyFordTouch controls.
If
I had a dollar for every showgoer who said, "That’s
the Fusion?" … well, I’d probably buy a Mustang
GT convertible, but that’s just me.
HIT:
2013 Cadillac ATS: Very few cars have ever looked better
on paper than the ATS sport sedan: a 51/49 weight
distribution for balance and handling, a 270-horsepower
2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine, magnetic
ride control and Cadillac’s latest voice-recognition
and infotainment system.
The
chassis pioneers a new way to reduce weight, one of GM’s
biggest challenges. The exterior design is another
effective example of Cadillac’s signature look.
Cadillac
developed the ATS in Detroit to meet or beat the BMW 3
series. When you come at the king, you best not miss.
MISS:
Scion FR-S and Subaru BRZ: Quick, without looking at the
badges, tell me which of these cars is the Subaru and
which is the Scion.
Jointly
developed by Toyota and Subaru, the Scion FR-S (in
white) and Subaru BRZ (in blue) are an affront to the
idea that brand identity matters.
Toyota
preens about the FR-S’ intentional similarity to the
brand’s 2000GT, while Subaru mumbles that the BRZ pays
"some homage to classic GT-type sports cars."
The
sheer cynicism of the entire project is doubly sad
because the lightweight rear-drive coupe will probably
be a delight to drive.
HIT:
Acura NSX concept: Impossibly low and wide, this hybrid
exotic sports car bears the weight of Acura’s dreams.
Honda’s
luxury brand has slipped in recent years. Oddball looks
and so-so performance left it behind other luxury
brands.
With
a mid-mounted V6 engine and a pair of electric motors
— each providing power independently to one front
wheel — the NSX constitutes a one-vehicle campaign to
re-establish Acura as a leader in efficiency, design and
performance.
HIT:
2013 BMW 3 series sedan: The 3-series sedan showcases
BMW’s historic strengths. It’s roomier, faster and
more powerful than the car it replaces, but also weighs
less — depending on the engine — and should get
higher fuel economy.
The
base 328i’s new turbocharged 2.0-liter engine
generates more power than the 3.0-liter straight-six it
replaces. An eight-speed automatic transmission is
available, and a hybrid arrives later this year.
HIT:
2013 Dodge Dart: The Dart compact sedan hints at great
things to come from Chrysler’s alliance with Fiat.
Its
broad cross-hair grille and sporty stance make it
immediately recognizable as a Dodge, but engineers in
Auburn Hills stretched and widened the platform of the
sporty Alfa Romeo Giulietta to create a car that
promises up to 40 mpg on the highway and more rear
legroom than a Hyundai Sonata midsize sedan.
A
year from now, we’ll see how Chrysler and Fiat
engineering made new models for the Jeep and Chrysler
brands. This is a good start.
MISS:
Chrysler 700C concept: Chrysler boss Sergio Marchionne
has a love-hate relationship with his company’s
minivans. He loves the money they make, but hates the
fact that Dodge and Chrysler sell two largely identical
vehicles.
The
ungainly 700C is not the answer. Its long hood recalls
the failed GM minivans that tried desperately to pass
for SUVs.
Every
other automaker would love to have a pair of minivans
that combined for 200,000-plus sales last year. Chrysler
should just suck it up and admit that making minivans is
the business it chose.
HIT:
Maserati Kubang: This SUV promises to combine
Ferrari-built engines, lavish Maserati design and
Detroit engineering and assembly.
If
it delivers a unique luxury-performance SUV, the Kubang
will open new doors for Italian premium brands and
American technology and workmanship.
Legend
has it the awkward name — first used on a Maserati
concept SUV in 2003 — originated as a Ferrari
executive’s practical joke on the Italian brand, which
had been a rival until Fiat acquired it. Don’t worry:
The Kubang concept is destined for production. Its name
isn’t.
HIT:
Chevrolet Code 130R concept: You can think of this small
and fuel-efficient rear-wheel drive coupe as a mini-Camaro
or a BMW 1 series at a Chevrolet price.
Either
way, I think I love it, and I wish Chevy would build it.
HIT:
Lexus LF-LC concept: Long, low and elegant, this luxury
coupe is everything Lexus’ last big two-door was not.
The
SC 430 hardtop convertible was an overstuffed pillow on
wheels: soft and soporific. The lithe LF-LC concept
recalls Lexus’ first coupe, the legitimately sporty SC
300.
Lexus
wants to become an emotional brand. The LF-LC is a good
first step.
MISS:
Honda Accord coupe concept: The Accord coupe concept —
nearly identical to the model that goes on sale later
this year — isn’t the car that will inject new
excitement into the Honda brand.
The
design is evolutionary and the big new technical
features — a direct-injection engine and six-speed
automatic transmission — are old hat.
Honda
had better hope the Accord sedan that also goes on sale
this year has a little more spice.