The 2010
LaCrosse is Super-Buick, but will buyers see past Clark
Kent's glasses?
Buick created the sleek, contemporary
sedan to restore its status as a premium marque, attract
younger buyers and compete with entry-luxury sedans like
the Acura TL and Lexus ES 350.
The once-proud brand has sunk into
mild-mannered anonymity, thanks to decades of cars that
had high quality ratings but low curb appeal.
Buick needs a hero.
The all-new LaCrosse has the looks,
comfort and performance to do the job, if buyers
recognize the stylish sheet metal, good handling and
roomy, well-appointed interior and value hiding behind
the Buick badge.
The great unanswered question of the
Superman saga is: How could Lois Lane be so dumb? Clark
Kent puts on a pair of glasses and she can't tell he's
the Man of Steel? Every kid who ever picked up a comic
book believed he or she wouldn't make that mistake.
The 2010 LaCrosse leaps over the ES
350 and TL in a single bound. Shoppers who look past the
geeky glasses of the Buick badge may find something
super.
"That's a nice-looking car. What
is it?" asked Anne, a chic acquaintance who saw me
in a parking lot. Craning around to see the rear badge,
she answered her own question: "Oh, it's a Buick.
Ewww, it's a Buick."
Buick gave the all-new LaCrosse
midsize sedan two missions:
—Beat the pants off lower-luxury
midsize sedans like the Lexus ES 350 and Acura TL.
—Change people's reaction to Buick
from "Ewww" to "Oooh."
The LaCrosse succeeds handsomely at
Job 1. It's roomier, quieter, more comfortable and a
better value.
As tough as topping Lexus and Acura's
top midsize sedans is, the LaCrosse's second task is
more daunting: get people to take a closer look and see
the excellent car behind the badge they dismiss.
The roomy LaCrosse is all-new for
2010. Based on a new architecture and developed in
China, the United States and Europe, the only thing the
car shares with the previous LaCrosse is its name.
The LaCrosse comes in front- and
all-wheel drive models and offers either a 3.0-liter or
3.6-liter V6 engine.
A six-speed automatic transmission is
standard on all LaCrosse models. The 3.0-liter engine
generates 255 horsepower in front-drive models and 252
with AWD.
The 3.6-liter produces 280 horsepower.
It's only available with front-wheel drive now, but
don't be surprised if Buick adds an AWD model with the
bigger engine.
LaCrosse prices start at $27,085 for a
front-drive CX model. The mid-range CXL starts at
$29,645 for front-drive and $31,820 for all-wheel drive.
Prices for the CXS start at $33,015. I
tested a well-equipped LaCrosse CXS that stickered at
$36,330. All prices exclude destination charges.
LaCrosse pricing compares favorably
with entry-luxury midsize sedans like the Acura TL,
Lexus ES 350, Lincoln MKZ and Nissan Maxima. The Buick
has a lower base price, and models equipped comparably
with the LaCrosse I tested cost $1,200 to $7,000 more
than the Buick.
The LaCrosse's 101.7-cubic-foot
interior offers more passenger space than those
competitors, though its trunk is smaller than all but
the Maxima. The trunk opening is somewhat inconveniently
shaped for loading big suitcases.
The LaCrosse's passenger compartment
is attractive and comfortable. Rear leg and headroom are
excellent. That's no surprise, since LaCrosse
development was heavily influenced by the Chinese
market, where the car is a hit and frequently owned by
chauffeur-driven big shots.
That may also explain the shortage of
front-seat storage cubbies — the hired help isn't
expected to bring their iPod, purse and other
accessories. The large center console has little useful
stowage. The front cupholders' location far back in the
center console could also be more convenient.
The interior materials are uniformly
good. The design is restrained and elegant, though some
pieces of trim do not line up perfectly.
Buick may have optimized the front
seat for chauffeurs, but the LaCrosse's handling was
clearly tuned for people who enjoy driving themselves.
The sedan stays flat and planted while negotiating fast
curves.
The steering provides good feel and
quick response. The ride is smooth and quiet, with very
little wind or road noise at high speed.
Front-drive models have very mild
torque steer under heavy acceleration. The AWD LaCrosse
may appeal to enthusiasts, but the FWD car handles
admirably.
Both engines provide good performance
and fuel economy. The EPA rated the front-wheel drive
LaCrosse at 17 m.p.g. in the city and 27 m.p.g. on the
highway.
The all-wheel drive model scored 16
city/26 highway. The front-drive LaCrosse's fuel economy
roughly matches or slightly exceeds the TL, ES 350, MKZ
and Maxima. The LaCrosse uses regular gasoline, while
the Acura, Lexus and Nissan require more expensive
premium.
The LaCrosse lacks a few features a
prestigious sedan should offer, however. The power seats
do not automatically return to the last driven position
after sliding to the convenient easy entry/exit
position. The voice-command system works well with the
navigation system, but is less user-friendly than
Lincoln's Sync feature.
The sleek styling sets the tone for
future Buicks with elegant touches like the flowing
"sweep spear" — a design term from Buick's
past — rising along the rear fenders. The new hood-top
placement of the chrome portholes — another visual cue
from the brand's heyday — works well.
Buick has a long way to go before its
status matches Lexus or Acura. With the 2010 LaCrosse,
the brand has a car that surpasses them and takes a
significant first step from "ewww" to "oooh."
———
BUICK LACROSSE CXS
Front-wheel drive five-seat midsize
sedan
Rating: 4 out of 4 stars
Price as tested: $36,330 (excluding
destination charge)
Reasons to buy: Looks, handling,
passenger space, value
Shortcomings: Interior storage,
interior trim fit, trunk size