"The
Stone Gods" by Jeanette Winterson; Harcourt ($24)
___
In many
ways, Jeanette Winterson remains a fearless writer.
Like few modern literary novelists she pursues her
unfashionable but characteristic subject - romantic
love - even when the quest leads to fundamentalist
religion, as in her award-winning autobiographical
debut, "Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit"; the
Napoleonic wars, in "The Passion"; or the
intrigue surrounding the 16th-century tulip trade, in
"The PowerBook."
Combined
with a lyrical yet forceful prose style and a
disarming bent toward the fantastic, Winterson's
persistent focus on romantic love - or perhaps, more
precisely, the romance (the glamour, the magic, the
transcendence) of love - allows her to deliver the
kind of rare pleasure found only in works of equal
skill and unfettered imagination. Isak Dinesen's
"Seven Gothic Tales" comes to mind.
Alas,
as exemplified by her latest novel, "The Stone
Gods," Winterson does seem to have one phobia,
shared by all too many serious writers: fear of genre,
of telling a story so well in, say, the form of
science fiction, that it risks being considered less
than a work of literary art. Her counterstratagem,
also shared by too many serious writers, is that long
since tiresome exercise known as metafiction.
More's
the pity, for the first half of "The Stone
Gods" is a fully realized dystopian sci-fi tale,
brilliantly conceived and deftly constructed.
On the
planet Orbus, a corporation, MORE, rules the former
first world in benevolent tyranny, distracting its
subjects from the collapsing natural environment with
reality television shows and the fruits of higher
technology, such as universal cosmetic surgery, robot
traffic police and personal pollution filters. The
globe's remaining territory is divided between an
Islamic power known as the Eastern Caliphate, and the
SinoMosco Pact, comprising the former Eurasian
communist territories.
It is,
naturally, our own planet, plausibly described a
century or two hence, when it likely will be
succumbing to pollution, global warming and the
"benefits" of advancing technology. The
heroine, Billie Crusoe, is that familiar type, the
rebellious government agent. She works for Enhancement
("It's my job in Enhancement to explain to people
that they really do want to live their lives in a way
that is good for them and good for the Community.
Enforcement steps in when it doesn't quite work
out"), but she also bucks the system, and even
hides members of the Resistance from time to time.
Fed up
with Billie's attitude but unable to prove anything,
MORE smacks her with $3 million in bogus traffic
fines. She's given the choice of arrest, or joining a
trip to a newly discovered blue planet, where humanity
hopes to relocate for a fresh, more eco-friendly
start. She accepts the space mission, where her
principle companions are the dashing Capt. Handsome;
Pink, a woman who won the trip on a reality show; and
Spike, a beautiful woman of the species "Robo
sapiens."
Their
mission is to sling an asteroid at the new planet,
thereby killing off the dinosaurs, so inconvenient to
human habitation. Along the way, each character gains
new shadings - even Pink, at first an airhead, proves
resilient and likable - and Billie falls in love with
Spike, who has developed an ability not found in her
original programming. She can feel emotions.
The
power and depth of the society Winterson creates
overshadows the two following sections, one set in
another culture dying of ecological abuses,
18th-century Easter Island, the other in an advanced
civilization that mirrors the first, and thus our own.
Reading about Billy, a marooned sailor who falls in
love with a native man named Spikkers, or another
version of Billie, this time in love with a robot
named Spike who consists of only a head, is pale work
after the narrative energy and imaginative verve of
the first 93 pages.
In the
last section, especially, Winterson allows ideas to
overwhelm narrative. It's chock-a-block with lines
like: "Everything is imprinted for ever with what
it once was." Or "A quantum universe -
neither random nor determined." "Love is an
intervention. Why do we not choose it?" The
message throttles the medium.
Besides,
Winterson's big idea - humanity, given the chance,
would ruin one planet, island or life, after another,
endlessly - is fully developed in the beginning
section. While she labors mightily throughout the rest
of the book to deliver something literary and
meaningful, Winterson gains little, having already
achieved her loftiest aims in the mere sci-fi
dystopian satire she begins with.