WASHINGTON — The
House voted Thursday to repeal the federal tax on
estates, a politically volatile issue that affects few
Republicans refer to it as the "death tax." They say it
prevents small business owners and family farmers from
passing businesses on to their heirs.
"Can you imagine working your whole life to build up a
family-owned business and then upon your death Uncle Sam
swoops in and takes nearly half of what you spent a
lifetime building up for your children and
grandchildren?" asked Rep. Kevin Brady, R-Texas, who
sponsored the bill.
"It is at its heart an immoral tax," he said.
Democrats say repealing the tax is a giveaway to the
rich, since the only families that pay it have many
millions in assets. The bill now goes to the Senate
where Democrats appear to have enough votes to block it.
The White House has threatened to veto the bill in part
because it would add $269 billion to the budget deficit
over the next decade.
"This proposed repeal of the estate tax is nothing more
than a massive unfunded tax break for a small sliver of
America's wealthiest families," said Rep. Jim McDermott,
D-Wash. "What are they doing? Shoveling a quart of a
trillion dollars out the door to the richest."
The vote was 240-179.
The House also passed a bill to make permanent a
deduction for state and local sales taxes that expired
at the beginning of the year. The White House threatened
to veto that bill in part because it would have added
$42 billion to the budget deficit over the next decade.
The federal tax rate on estates is 40 percent, but big
exemptions limit the share of estates that pay it to
fewer than 1 percent.
This year, the exemption is $5.43 million for a single
person. Married couples can exempt up to $10.9 million.
Larger estates pay taxes only on the amounts above these
A total of 5,400 estates are expected to pay the tax
this year — out of about 2.6 million deaths, according
to the nonpartisan Joint Committee on Taxation, which
provides official estimates for Congress. That's 0.2
percent of all deaths in the U.S.
Republicans say that some business owners get hit with
the tax because they have valuable assets that don't
necessarily generate a lot of cash. They cite family
farms, which may sit on valuable land but don't generate
enough money to pay hefty estate taxes unless heirs sell
some or all the land.
"The super rich? They don't pay this tax. They have a
legion of lawyers and tax planners. They have charitable
trusts and foundations," Brady said. "These are
family-owned, hard-working, risk-taking, determined
Americans who are building their business, their farm,
their ranch. These are not, as we will hear today, the
Paris Hiltons and robber barons of the Teddy Roosevelt
The deduction for state and local sales taxes helps
people who live in the nine states without a state
income tax on wages.
House Republicans say the measure is about fairness
because people in states that have incomes taxes can
deduct those taxes on their federal returns.
The vote was 272-152.
These seven states have no state income tax: Alaska,
Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington and
Wyoming. Also, New Hampshire and Tennessee tax income
from interest and dividends, but not wages.
The deduction is one of dozens of temporary tax breaks
that are routinely extended every year or two. House
Republicans are working to make selected ones permanent.