ANTELOPE, Calif. —
Some things about middle school PE class never change. The
uniforms, drab and ill-fitting mesh, remain about as stylish
as a leisure suit. Students still scramble to plop down on
their assigned number stenciled onto the blacktop before the
bell. And afterward, just as in days of yore, no one ever even
thinks of taking a shower.
Those are the hoary physical education
traditions, seemingly handed down from generation to
generation.
Yet much truly has changed – evolved is
more like it – in the modern middle school and high school
PE class. Changed for the better, educators say, especially
considering the nation's bloated rate of childhood obesity and
alarming predictions about increases in juvenile-onset
diabetes.
Gone is the epoch – in many secondary
school programs, at least – when the teacher would just roll
out the balls and tell kids to go play, when students would
pick blades of grass in the outfield during softball
"instruction," their heart rates barely rising about
resting levels.
These days, you're more likely to find
students checking the heart-rate monitors they've strapped on
during jump rope to "stay in the zone," try for that
aerobic threshold on the step trainer, and harden those
abdominals and obliques with side planks.
Core training in middle school?
Abs-olutely.
Check out this scene from a recent
seventh-grade PE class at Antelope Crossing Middle School in
Antelope, Calif., which in 2008 was named one of four
"star schools" in the nation, so designated by the
National Association for Sport and Physical Education, or
NASPE.
Twenty-five seventh-graders, fresh off a
warm-up run, perform ab crunches with arms folded over their
chests. Occasional groaning and bellyaching can be heard
("Owww, my stomach hurrrrts!"), to which teacher
Laurel Whaley good-naturedly replies, "Oh, come on.
Groaning makes you strong."
Over on the next patch of blacktop, teacher
Meghan Jinguji presides over push-ups ("Good pushes from
the knees are better than bad ones from the toes")
followed by high-knee strides and lateral movement.
And around the corner, a boombox is blaring
Michael Jackson's "Thriller" and the Romantics'
"What I Like About You" as the students sweat it out
on circuit training. The music might be straight out of the
'80s, but the activity is state of the art: one-minute
rotations on a variety of aerobic and strength-training
stations, from step platforms to resistance bands to biceps
curls.
After 25 minutes, teacher Brian Willey
gathers the class on a blustery morning.
"You're sweating a little bit," he
says, "that's a good thing. OK, so what was one component
of fitness we worked on here?"
Hands shoot up.
"Cardiovascular endurance," one
boy says.
Willey: "What's one station that did
that?"
"The ladder," another student
replies.
As its designation as a national
award-winning program attests, Antelope Crossing is on the
cutting edge of the latest trend in elementary and secondary
school physical education principles: to engage students into
lifelong physical activity and educate them on the proper
form, function and philosophy of a variety of skills in
individual and team sports as well as understand concepts such
as optimal heart rate and effort for aerobic activity.
In simpler terms, the kids actually do
something in PE and learn fitness skills they can carry to
adulthood.
Case in point, says teacher Jinguji:
"The (heart rate) monitors help our sixth-graders learn
how to pace themselves. The way most come in doing a (mile)
run is to start at high intensity, then recover, then sprint,
walk, sprint, walk. When they have the monitor on, they can
actually see how it's better to pace themselves. They see the
graph and it connects the dots for them."
That's a far cry, indeed, from the days when
the most strenuous thing a PE student did was line up for roll
call.
California physical educators in 2006
adopted content standards that address the skills, concepts
and measures needed by students in each grade level.
Seventh-graders must master how to assess their muscle
strength, endurance, aerobic capacity and body composition.
They work with a teacher to set up a weekly personal fitness
program and perform "moderate to vigorous" physical
activity at least four days a week.
That's in addition, of course, to the 200
minutes of PE every two weeks from grades one to six, and 400
minutes every two weeks for grades seven to 12 that have long
been part of the state's education code.
Still, if your child doesn't know aerobic
from Abercrombie & Fitch, don't be surprised.
Many schools have been slow to implement the
standards that the state Board of Education developed for
physical education in 2006. And because PE is not part of the
Academic Performance Index (i.e., standardized testing), there
is no oversight or penalty for not reaching goals.
Dianne Wilson-Graham, former California
president of the American Alliance for Physical Education,
Recreation and Dance, has been a close observer of physical
education curriculum. She says schools are all over the map
when it comes to compliance.
Lack of funding and commitment by school
districts is one factor for the lag, she says. But she also
puts the blame on many physical educators who cling to the old
way of teaching.
"We still have folks who are tied to
what they did in 1968," Wilson-Graham says. "My joke
to them always is, 'When I was in seventh grade, we didn't
have microwave ovens. Do you have one in your house now?' We
have to get the public to understand there are dramatic
changes happening and help our school decision-makers
understand that, too."
Antelope's Jinguji, who is a vice president
of the American Alliance for Physical Education, Recreation
and Dance's California chapter, has served as an evaluator of
student PE teachers and also does outside work helping
teachers with professional development.
The goal, she says, is for teachers to
develop "physically literate individuals" by the
time they leave high school.
Most PE classes still focus on team sports
"requiring sporadic and/or limited physical
activity," according to a recent report from the federal
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The report states
that adding "lifestyle activities," such as running,
weightlifting and personalized fitness programs, would better
serve students.
Moreover, a 2006 NASPE "Shape of the
Nation" report on school PE calls school requirements
"weak." Jacalyn Lund, NAPSE president, said "a
vast array of 'loopholes' such as exemptions, waivers and
online classes too often eradicate those minimum standards at
the local level at a time when more and more children are
obese ..."
The CDC reports that 73 percent of high
school students fail to attain minimum levels of physical
activity to maintain health by the time they graduate.
Those out-of-shape teens often become
sedentary adults, educators say. The key is to instill the
habit and, yes, even a love of physical activity before it's
too late. Few California elementary schools provide PE
specialists, which is why the middle-school years are so
important.
"It's a struggle, because you're always
going to run into kids more and less motivated," says
Zachary Lovell, a PE teacher at Arden Middle School in
Sacramento. If you give kids the basic movement skills to
apply through a variety of activities, they'll feel more
competent when they get older.
"Using heart-rate (monitors) and
pedometers to measure makes them understand the difference
between aerobic and anaerobic exercise. As they get older, if
they think they're interested in running a 5K or
half-marathon, they'll understand the specificity of the
training."
Some elementary schools in Placer County
have, in essence, outsourced PE by using the nonprofit Running
School Inc., headed by former pro triathlete Brad Kearns.
Kearns and crew serve as de facto coaches for the students,
preparing them for the "Fitnessgram," an age-graded
test to determine levels of fitness.
This year, at First Street Elementary School
in Lincoln, 90 percent of the students attained the
Fitnessgram standard after working with Running School Inc.
staff members, Kearns says.
At Antelope Crossing, Jinguji stresses the
education component as much as the activity level.
All Antelope Crossing, seventh-graders turn
in a bulky fitness portfolio, which includes printouts of
their fitness scores, body mass index (BMI), graphs of
heart-rate fluctuations in different activities, and
appraisals of their nutrition intake, stress and body weight.
Eighth-graders concentrate mostly on team
sports, but they also must pick a "lifetime" sport
and conduct research on where opportunities to play exist.
The emphasis on team sports is one area
that's been a constant in school PE over the years. During a
street hockey game at Antelope Crossing, several players stood
in place a lot, simply watching the puck being slapped around.
Jinguji, though, defends the use of team
sports for eighth-graders. And, she says, they do cardio and
warm-up before commencing games.
"We make sure they are small-sided
games," she says. "Some research out there says you
should never have more than six on a side, for maximum
participation and lots of movement. There's never a lot of
standing around. We have three soccer fields and play across
the width of the fields."
And while she admits that once the students
become adults, it's unlikely they will continue in team
sports, "We philosophically believe that the more skills
you have, the more likely you'll be able to pursue a lifetime
physical activity because you'll be a better mover. We teach
concepts that cross over."
Students at Antelope Crossing are thinking
of the future, though. Some say they "endure" PE;
others like being physical and realize they need to get in
shape.
"It's a good workout," says Kavion
Pickett, a seventh-grader with sweat beading on his forehead
after vigorous rope jumping. "I need to lose some weight.
My whole family does. This seems like a good way to do
it."
Complaints during crunches notwithstanding,
the level of participation at the school is impressive.
"I mean, I've never liked PE,"
says seventh-grader Lorena Balic, "but they make it good.
It's challenging but not like you work until you die."
Then there's sixth-grader Nick Risinger, who
has an entirely different reason for looking forward to PE.
"I've been grounded at home," he
says, sheepishly, "so it's nice just to be outside."