Ginkgo biloba is
probably the herb most widely used in the United States and
Europe by people hoping to prevent memory decline and
dementia. If you're someone who has been taking this herb to
keep your brain healthy, you may want to reconsider where you
spend your money.
You may recall that in 2008, the Ginkgo
Evaluation of Memory study, or GEM, concluded that ginkgo was
ineffective in reducing the incidence or progression of
Alzheimer's disease and other types of dementia. However,
given previous studies suggesting that ginkgo might be useful
for people with milder cognitive impairment, the GEM group
also decided to look at the effect of ginkgo on cognitive
decline in normal older adults or adults with only mild
cognitive impairment.
The resulting study, published last month in
the Journal of the American Medical Association, suggests that
ginkgo is not helpful in preventing cognitive decline in older
adults. In this study, more than 3,000 adults with normal
cognition or mild cognitive impairment, ages 72 to 96, were
randomized to receive either ginkgo (120 mg, twice daily) or a
placebo for about six years.
At the end of the study, the researchers
found no differences between the ginkgo and placebo groups in
their assessment of memory, attention and language, or rate of
decline in cognitive impairment. Age, gender, race and
education did not seem to have any impact on the outcomes.
The authors concluded that ginkgo biloba
taken in that amount was ineffective in preventing cognitive
decline in older adults with either normal cognitive function
or mild cognitive impairment.
Ginkgo has intrigued researchers as a brain
supplement because it seems to have a positive effect on blood
vessels in the brain -- it dilates them, thins the blood a bit
(thought to enhance circulation) and functions as an
antioxidant.
In addition, animal studies have suggested
it may inhibit amyloid protein in the brain, which is a cause
of Alzheimer's disease. However, the data have been
inconsistent about positive effects in humans, and this most
recent study is not encouraging.
In addition, the Cochrane Library, an
international nonprofit organization that reviews the efficacy
of health care interventions, reviewed 36 research studies of
ginkgo in 2009 and concluded that while ginkgo biloba appears
to be safe and without significant side effects, it does not
seem to reduce the risk of cognitive decline or dementia.
That said, several other lifestyle choices
and supplements are showing some promise:
—Fish: Observational studies show a link
between a high intake of fish and a reduced risk of
Alzheimer's disease as well as a reduced risk of cognitive
decline in non-demented individuals.
—Vitamin D: A 2009 British study showed
that people with the lowest levels of vitamin D in their blood
were more than twice as likely to be cognitively impaired than
those with the highest levels.
—Vitamin E: It might help delay the
progression of Alzheimer's, but some data suggest vitamin E
may actually increase mortality. Stay tuned.
—Other nutrients: Adequate intake of
vitamin B3 (niacin), vitamin B12 and iron are all associated
with improved cognition.
—Turmeric: An observational study from
2006 showed that healthy people ages 60-93 who ate curry
(turmeric) at least once a month scored better on cognitive
tests than people who rarely ate curry.
—Diet: People who follow the Mediterranean
diet (high in plant food, low in animal food) seem to have a
lower risk of Alzheimer's.
—Stress: Chronic stress impairs the growth
of new brain cells and seems to lead to changes in memory.
Several other supplements look promising for
Alzheimer's disease, including huperzine A, phosphatidylserine,
acetyl-L-carnitine and vinpocetine, though long-term
effectiveness and safety are still unknown. Also, many of
these supplements can interact with other medicines, including
prescription drugs used for Alzheimer's as well as blood
thinners, so talk to your doctor before trying any.
And of course, do everything you can to
prevent dementia in the first place: Stay active, stay with a
healthy diet and healthy weight, and stay engaged in your
community. Your aging destiny is largely in your hands.