CHICAGO -
Barely a decade after American children started getting
vaccinations for chickenpox, the once-universal disease of
childhood has virtually disappeared from many parts of the
country, according to a report released Tuesday.
Some parents
still hesitate to get their children immunized for what they
consider a low-risk illness, but many doctors say the
vaccine has drastically cut back on children's sick days and
reduced potentially fatal complications. In Illinois, which
requires schoolchildren to be vaccinated before starting
kindergarten, chickenpox cases have declined more than 95
percent since 1994, the year before the vaccine was
introduced.
Deaths
related to chickenpox have nearly vanished, with just 15
annual fatalities estimated nationwide, according to the
paper in Tuesday's edition of the journal Pediatrics, which
reviewed a decade of research on the vaccine's effects.
Not long ago,
most children could relate to the miserable plight of
Michael Anzalotti, an 18-month-old from Chicago's Northwest
Side who caught the disease in May, just before an
appointment to get immunized. Now doctors say the illness is
so rare that many medical students no longer know how to
diagnose it.
Michael's
mother, Jennifer Anzalotti, was startled to look behind her
son's ear and find the first pock, which had the telltale
look of a dewdrop on a rose petal.
"I still
don't know where he got it, to be honest," said
Anzalotti, whose family kept Michael away from other
children for more than two weeks to avoid passing on his
illness.
Serious side
effects of chickenpox are rarer than ever, but they are
real, experts say. The illness can lead to skin infections,
inflammation of the brain and pneumonia. Such side effects
happen most often in otherwise healthy patients, studies
have found.
Before the
chickenpox vaccine, more than 10,000 people were
hospitalized each year with such complications, and nearly
half of them were children under 5. But the new report found
that hospitalizations have decreased by more than 75 percent
in the last decade, with the largest reductions among
children.
"Sometimes
people don't realize that chickenpox could be that
severe," said Dr. Mona Marin, report co-author and a
medical epidemiologist at the Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention's division of viral diseases.
___
LEERY PARENTS
Convincing
parents of the need for the vaccine still can be difficult.
Elizabeth Wright of Chicago said she complies with the
state's vaccination requirements for her three children but
is leery of getting them any shots beyond that, such as the
relatively new vaccine for human papillomavirus.
Wright said
she plans on sticking with the required one dose of
chickenpox vaccine, even though the CDC recommended in 2006
that children get two doses to ensure protection.
"It's
almost like we're doing this just to avoid having them
getting itchy for a week," she said of the chickenpox
vaccine. "If they don't have to have the vaccine, I'd
rather they not have it."
Very few
parents refuse only the chickenpox vaccine; typically the
ones who avoid it are those who say no to all vaccines, said
Dr. Paul Luning, chief medical officer of the PCC Community
Wellness Center in Oak Park, Ill.
The new
report found conflicting evidence for a unique concern about
chickenpox vaccine: the idea that it could lead to an
increase in shingles among older people.
Shingles is a
painful skin rash most common in people older than 65,
caused by a reactivation of the chickenpox virus that they
contracted earlier in life. Some scientists believe being
exposed to children with chickenpox can act as a sort of
natural "booster shot" for older people, sparking
their immune systems and reducing the risk that their virus
will reappear as shingles.
In theory the
chickenpox vaccine could be short-circuiting that natural
protection by reducing the number of children with
chickenpox, thereby removing the natural booster that older
people would have received. By cutting down on disease in
one group, the vaccine may indirectly boost a related
disease among older people.
"It's a
theoretical concern; it makes sense, but nobody knows,"
said Dr. Ben Katz, a specialist in pediatric infectious
diseases at Children's Memorial Hospital in Chicago.
The CDC's
Marin said two of the studies her team examined found that
the chickenpox vaccine had boosted shingles rates, but two
other studies found no effect.
In some ways
the chickenpox vaccine may be more helpful now than when it
was released in the 1990s, said Dr. Kenneth Polin of Town
& Country Pediatrics in Chicago. That is because of the
increase in drug-resistant staph infections, which can use
chickenpox sores to gain entry into the body.
"When
kids scratch a pox lesion, it can allow the bacteria to get
into the skin," Polin said. "We want to do
anything we can to reduce the likelihood of that."
___
'CHICKENPOX
PARTIES'
Some parents
who are leery of the vaccine actually welcome contact with
infected children in the form of "chickenpox
parties," intended to spread the disease and give
unvaccinated children protection from it in the future.
Such
get-togethers may have made sense in the pre-vaccine era,
when the disease seemed inevitable and evidence suggested
that children often had milder infections than adults. But
most doctors strongly advise against such parties now,
citing the potential for hospitalization and even death.
"It's
really an archaic kind of thing," said Dr. Jaye
Schreier, a pediatrician at Advocate Lutheran General
Children's Hospital in Park Ridge, Ill. "We could also
go down to the river with a washboard and clean our clothes
that way, but let's not."
The rapid
transformation of chickenpox into an unfamiliar, almost
exotic disease has decreased familiarity of the illness
among parents and even doctors. Several doctors said they
now see perhaps two cases a year, making the diagnosis more
challenging.
Fifty years
ago, many mothers could diagnose diseases such as measles,
whooping cough and chickenpox on their own because the
diseases were so common, said Katz of Children's Memorial.
"Now we
don't see those diseases anymore, so when they crop up,
parents aren't as good at doing the diagnosis," he
said. "They're just going to have to call us for
that."