Tracey Williams is
used to her friends' questions about food safety: The recent
MBA graduate from Southern Methodist University also sports a
master's degree in meat science from Texas A&M.
Recent alarming reports about the safety of
ground beef have made the questions even more timely.
Williams' bottom line: "I think the
average consumer just needs to know how to properly prepare
meat," she said. "And I think most people don't
follow all the steps."
Even so, she buys her burger meat in a store
where she knows it's ground fresh daily from sources she can
identify — which can be impossible to do with most
commercially prepared hamburger.
Choosing their stores and reading their
labels carefully is a first step for shoppers worried about
what goes into their ground beef. Williams and other meat
experts say the consumer's last — and always effective —
line of defense is a food thermometer and a spray bottle of
kitchen cleaner.
The main risk posed by ground beef is the
bacteria E. coli. A recent New York Times story highlighted
one woman's suffering from a hamburger-borne infection and
potential gaps in the chain of monitoring the safety of
processed ground beef.
E. coli is an all-but unavoidable microbe
found in many animals and inside most people. Most strains are
harmless, or even beneficial. The strain called O157:H7
creates a chemical that is intensely poisonous to people.
That strain is one of several that make
people sick and are sometimes found in meat or on raw
vegetables. The Dallas County, Texas, Health Department
recorded 29 E. coli illnesses last year and 13 this year, but
the statistics do not reflect the source of the infection.
In most cases, people recover from the
illness. But the Times story recounted the case of a woman
whose infection left her paralyzed from the waist down. Her
contaminated burger came from a company that mixes meats from
many sources into its ground beef.
That's a common industry practice, used for
most of the hamburger found on local food shelves. That means
food safety depends on the care taken at multiple locations
— in several states and countries.
For example, it's perfectly legal for meat
processors to blend cheap, lean pieces of meat with fat that
has been extracted from slaughterhouse trimmings that have
been frozen, pressed, cooked, separated and treated with
ammonia.
But the system is not necessarily more
dangerous than more narrowly controlled hamburger production,
said Daniel Hale, a professor of meat science at Texas A&M
University. Ground beef is tested by meat processors,
commercial suppliers, and even by some retailers, he said. And
while that system may need strengthening, it cannot guarantee
that any particular hamburger will be free of E. coli.
"You can't test your way out of this
problem," Hale said. "You cannot eliminate E coli
from the system. You are still going to have to cook it to
kill it."
E. coli can be found in cows' intestines and
feces. During the slaughtering process,despite efforts to
prevent it, some microbes can find their way onto thesurface
of meat.Grinding can work these microbes deep into the
mixture. Other steps in the industrial hamburger-making
process offer other opportunities for contamination, if proper
procedures aren't followed. Basic cuts of meat such as
briskets or steaks are something like lumber, chopped directly
from the source. Most ground beef is more like plywood, an
engineered product created to meet specific consumer goals of
standardized taste, fat content, shelf-life and price.
And while spot checks are done for bacteria
at various stages of the process, even industry officials
acknowledge that some people still get sick, even as beef
producers have spent millions of dollars on research and
testing. Health officials say there are about 24,000 known
cases of meat related E coli related illness per year, with
many more minor cases going undiagnosed. The known cases
represent one illness for every 1.1 million pounds of beef
produced in the United States.
That's a pretty good record, beef producers
say. And while they stress the need for consumers to do their
part, they acknowledge the need to produce uncontaminated
meat.
"We can't say the consumer bears all
the responsibility for safe product," said Russell
Woodward a senior manager for the Texas Beef Council.
"That's irresponsible."
———
UNDERSTANDING THE LABELS
While most people use "ground
beef," "hamburger" and "beef patties"
interchangeably, federal regulations define them differently
if the meat is ground and packaged at a USDA-inspected plant.
Ground beef is just what it says: ground up
primal cuts and trimmings of raw cow.
Hamburger and beef patties can also contain
added beef fat, some of which can be mechanically and
chemically processed.
WHAT HAPPENS IN THE STORE
Consumers have many choices when it comes to
buying beef, and different shops may cut and grind it
differently to give buyers more options. Here's a general
rundown by type of store:
GROCERY STORES
Hamburger labeled simply as "ground
beef" can contain many cuts of beef from several sources.
Some "fresh ground" meats can be
minimally processed and coarse-ground at a plant before being
ground in the store.
Beef labeled by cut is supposed to contain
only that cut — meat labeled as "angus" should
contain only angus beef.
Many stores offer meat ground from the trim
of leftovers sliced in-store. This is often labeled as a
"family pack" and may be the cheapest burger on the
shelf.
Many grocery stores will custom-grind any
piece of beef in their store.
BUTCHERS AND HIGH-END GROCERS
Specialty butchers custom grind particular
cuts of meat, such as rib eye or sirloin, from specific
sources.
High-end markets such as Central Market and
Whole Foods grind their burger meat in the store from muscle
meats.
SOURCES: Dallas Morning News research
———
MEAT PREPARATION: STAYING SAFE
Experts say you can keep safe and avoid
illness by using the "three C's":
COLD: Refrigeration below 40 degrees
dramatically slows the growth of bacteria.
COOK: E. coli die after being exposed to 145
degrees of heat for 20 seconds. The official standard of 160
degrees for cooked hamburger offers additional safety.
CLEAN: Don't put cooked burgers where you
had the raw meat. Don't use kitchen tools on cooked burgers
that you used on raw meat. Clean all surfaces exposed to raw
meat with a solution of either bleach or vinegar before
putting other food down. Wash cutting boards in the
dishwasher.