Diets have taken a
hit in the last few years.
The world's most famous yo-yo dieter, Oprah
Winfrey, regained the weight once again and trumpeted the fact
on the cover of her magazine. Researchers at UCLA reviewed 31
diet studies and found that, within five years, most people
regain the weight. Even Weight Watchers distanced itself from
the dreaded D-word with its "Diets Don't Work; Weight
Watchers Does" campaign.
So why, we wondered, is the renowned Mayo
Clinic weighing in with a new diet book, the first in its
120-year history?
We talked to co-author Donald Hensrud,
chairman of the clinic's division of preventive and
occupational medicine.
Q: It's my understanding that, if you look
at medical studies, within four or five years most dieters
regain the weight.
A: In general, that's been true for a long
time. And if you look at any program that has follow-up out to
that length of time, that's generally true. However, a couple
of other questions need to be asked: Do we give up? Do we not
offer people anything at all? I don't think that's a good
option.
Secondly, there are success stories. The
National Weight Control Registry was established years ago,
and to get into this registry you have to lose 30 pounds and
keep it off for a year. They published an article some years
ago, where they looked at the experience of people, and the
average weight loss was 65 pounds, and people had kept it off
for an average of five years. So it is possible, and some
people do it.
Q: What makes your diet different?
A: The Mayo Clinic Diet is divided into two
phases: The "Lose It!" phase, which is a jump-start
phase, where people change habits suddenly, and the "Live
It!" phase, which takes those habits that they changed
and transitions them into a permanent lifestyle change. The
"Lose It!" phase, which is two weeks, is based on
adding five habits, breaking five habits and adopting five
bonus habits. The philosophy here is that people want to lose
weight, they want to see results right away, but many of the
methods to do that are either not healthy or not sustainable.
What we did in this phase is we took all the
things that have some evidence supporting them — either to
decrease calorie intake, increase energy expenditure, or
manage weight — and that are healthy, and (we) put them in
this. So the composite effect of making all these changes at
once is that it's effective, and we believe it's the
healthiest way to lose weight quickly there is.
Q: Do you have a favorite change?
A: The first one, eat a healthy breakfast.
It sounds very simple. But if you look at the medical
literature, there are numerous studies that show that people
who eat breakfast, in general, are more successful at managing
their weight.
One of the most challenging ones is no TV
while eating, and you can only watch as much TV as the time
you spend exercising.
Q: I saw that. That one hurt.
A: It does for many people! But it's only
for two weeks. It decreases a sedentary activity. It doesn't
necessarily have to, but it may promote increased activity or
exercise.
Some of the things we've heard from people
were, "I didn't realize I was capable of doing
this." You know, it does take people out of their comfort
zone, and it goes against the (clinic's) traditional doctrine:
Slow and steady to start out with, and you're more likely to
achieve (your goals) in the long term. But it also makes
people aware of their habits suddenly and how much they're
capable of changing.