How smart is your dog? 
A lot depends on you

August 27, 2008


Dr. Debra Horwitz, a veterinarian and board certified behaviorist, gives Baley, a lab mix, a treat during a training session at her home in Creve Coeur, Missouri.


 

ST. LOUIS - 
How smart is your dog? If you think it's just a matter of Fido's natural aptitude, think again. A lot depends on you. How well a dog learns to do what's expected of her - one common way of defining "intelligence" - is actually as much a function of time, patience, practice and environment as it is of canine I.Q., says Dr. Debra Horwitz, a veterinarian and board certified animal behaviorist from Creve Coeur, Mo.

If a dog is physically and neurologically healthy, it can learn new tasks at any age, Horwitz said.

But to bolster your dog's "intelligence," start training at a young age. Horwitz firmly believes that every dog has the ability to become more intelligent with proper training and positive reinforcement.

And she should know. Horwitz spends much of her time training pet owners to retrain their four-legged friends to correct behavior problems. We visited with her recently as she worked with Neela, a 1-year-old Siberian Husky, and Baley, a 20-month-old Labrador mix, to measure their "intelligence." After a few minutes of get-acquainted licking, slobbering and sniffing, they got down to business.

The first test, a smart walking technique, required learning to walk on a Gentle Leader head collar. Instead of a traditional collar around the dog's neck, the Gentle Leader has a nylon loop around the dog's muzzle and behind its ears. (In canine families, applying pressure on the muzzle is a gesture of dominance - mothers do it to calm rambunctious pups - prompting a submissive response.)

Baley, who was focused on the test, passed with flying colors. He went from pulling and darting on his leash to walking calmly with only a little instruction.

But Neela just wasn't into it. She didn't want to go for a walk, not even for a treat.

That doesn't mean that Neela isn't as smart as Baley, Horwitz said. It just means that Neela wasn't quite comfortable with the environment.

Dogs are like humans, Horwitz says. Some will never gain their highest potential of intelligence, just like humans. "You don't (need) a pure bred to have a smart dog," she said. Plenty of mutts have plenty of smarts.

Of course, some dogs have been bred over centuries for their talents in specific areas. For example, the border collie is the ideal breed for herding livestock. The breed is classified as intelligent for work. But because of its excitability and need for a job to do, the border collie wouldn't be considered "intelligent" in a home environment that didn't offer plenty of exercise and running-around time.

___

'DULL' ISN'T STUPID

Research shows that professional dog trainers and judges have found that even the "duller" breeds are capable of achieving high marks when it comes to learning. But findings also suggest that some brighter dogs show no interest in learning what we want them to.

Instead of thinking of your dog as "smart" or "dumb," try to understand what your dog likes to do, and why she might not understand the lessons you're trying to teach.

Try teaching tricks during quiet, calm times. If your dog can't do the task when it's relaxed and calm, he surely can't do it when he's stressed out and distracted.

Altering your training technique may yield amazing benefits. For dogs that like to jump up and down, for example, try teaching them to "dance." This channels their energy in a more appropriate way.

Keep in mind that some tasks, while not exclusive to one breed, are more prevalent in certain breeds. Any dog can be taught to follow a scent, but it's easier to teach that skill to scent hound or a hunting dog, Horwitz says.

Personality and temperament also have a huge effect on how well a dog adapts to training. A shy dog may find strong physical techniques overwhelming and be intimidated. A quick, energetic dog may find too much repetition boring and lose interest. Training techniques that focus on positive reinforcement as well as different ways to teach the same task will usually bring out the best in any dog, Horwitz said. Punitive training methods are less effective, and produce frightened, unhappy - and unpredictable - animals.

When you are clear in the response that you want, you are more likely to get it from your pet, she said.

In the end, Baley and Neela aren't all that different from us. Some days, we're up for a challenge. And some days we just don't feel like learning a darn thing.


McClatchy-Tribune Information Services