Wis. budget writers weigh tax, immigration policy

June 21, 2009

 
MADISON - Wisconsin lawmakers may decide in the next few days how much taxes you pay every time you fill up your car with gas, whether you have to buy car insurance and how your business investments are taxed.

Leaders of the Assembly and Senate are working to reconcile hundreds of differences in the budgets they passed.

The questions facing Assembly Speaker Mike Sheridan, Senate Majority Leader Russ Decker and their colleagues range from the major to the mundane. Whether the state should impose a new tax on oil companies? Make sure illegal immigrants are qualified to drive? Create a new income tax checkoff to benefit military families?

If agreement is reached, both houses of the Legislature could approve identical versions of the budget this week to send to Gov. Jim Doyle, who could use his veto power to make a final round of tweaks.

Legislative leaders are under pressure to come to terms quickly. The state could lose millions of dollars in federal money if the plan is not passed by July 1. Lawmakers also want to quickly enact spending cuts and tax and fee hikes to close a record-high $6.6 billion budget hole.

Here's a look at some of the issues negotiators must resolve. Action could come as early as Tuesday, when the Senate is scheduled to reconvene. Assembly leaders have likewise told members to be available all week to pass the budget.

TAXES: The biggest question facing lawmakers is how to make the budget balance through targeted tax increases.

The Assembly has approved a new assessment on oil companies, but would allow them to pass the cost on to consumers at the pump up to 4.4 cents per gallon. The plan is legally sound but politically risky because many drivers would be angered at having to pay higher gas taxes in a recession. It would raise about $224 million.

Doyle made a similar proposal, but barred the companies from passing the tax on to customers. The problem: many legal analysts believe the oil companies would have a strong chance at winning a lawsuit claiming that tax is illegal.

The Senate didn't approve any tax on oil companies. Instead, its budget would remove all exemptions from taxes on capital gains, which would tax business investors an additional $485 million over the next two years. Doyle and the Assembly only want to lower the current 60 percent exemption to 40 percent, which would raise $170 million.

Leaders of the Wisconsin Technology Council, which advises the governor and Legislature on policy, say the Senate plan would lead to less investment in all sectors of the economy and hurt startup businesses.

IMMIGRATION: Negotiators are weighing two hot-button issues related to immigration policy: whether to create a new driver's card for illegal immigrants and whether to allow them to qualify for in-state tuition at Wisconsin universities and technical colleges.

The Assembly approved both plans. The Senate rejected them.

The driver's cards would be given to illegal immigrants who pass the required tests to show they are qualified to drive. The cards would look different from driver's licenses and say in bold letters they could not be used for other official purposes. Only one other state, Utah, offers a similar card.

The in-state tuition measure would apply to illegal immigrants who graduate from Wisconsin high schools and have lived in the state three years. Right now they must pay out-of-state rates, which creates an insurmountable barrier for many low-income immigrants to higher education.

AUTO INSURANCE: The Senate would require all motorists in Wisconsin to have car insurance. The Assembly would keep current law, which makes Wisconsin the only state other than New Hampshire not to mandate car insurance.

DOJ FUNDING. The Assembly agreed to restore $5.4 million in funding for the Wisconsin Department of Justice after Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen mounted a public relations blitz warning cuts would cripple the agency. The Senate kept the deeper cuts in place and Decker has said they do not unfairly target the agency.

MILWAUKEE COUNTY SALES TAX: The Assembly budget would allow the Milwaukee County Board to increase sales taxes by 0.5 percentage points to fund transit and an additional 0.15 percentage point for local police and fire services. The Senate would go even further, allowing an increase of 1 percentage point for those and other purposes.

REGIONAL TRANSIT AUTHORITIES: The Assembly voted to allow regional transit authorities to be created in the Chippewa Valley and the Fox Valley pending local approval. The agencies could impose a sales tax up to 0.5 percentage points to fund transportation. The Senate did not approve either one, but added one of its own for far northern Wisconsin.

TAX CHECK-OFFS: The Assembly voted to allow Wisconsin residents the option to donate to Second Harvest Food Banks and a new relief fund for military families when they pay their income taxes. The Senate did not include either plan.

 

Associated Press