MADISON - In the weeks after Gov. Jim
Doyle's administration ordered state employees to curb unnecessary
travel, those same workers charged the state more than $900,000 for
hundreds of trips around the world.
Wisconsin state employees visited at
least 30 states and the District of Columbia and eight foreign
countries in more than 300 trips taken just the first three months
of the year, records obtained by The Associated Press show.
Expenses for the trips ranged from a
measly $10.83 each for five Department of Transportation workers who
attended a forum in Rosemont, Ill., to $12,000 for an Investment
Board analyst who made company visits in Tokyo.
The amount spent on travel and the
number of places visited actually is much greater than the reports
show. The University of Wisconsin System, which last fiscal year
accounted for about 89 percent of the out-of-state travel, submitted
an incomplete report.
The university showed just $461,000
in travel, but that did not include the entire month of January or
any travel directly related to its core mission or growth agenda,
said university spokesman David Giroux.
The information was not included due
to accounting limitations and because the university was told by
Doyle's administration that it didn't have to be included, Giroux
said.
It's not known how overall spending
on travel so far this year matches up with the same time period in
2007. Department of Administration Secretary Michael Morgan ordered
the report for the first time this year.
But the total amount reported appears
to be low. For the previous fiscal year, which covered July 1, 2006,
through June 30, 2007, out-of-state travel not paid for with federal
funds cost the state about $22.1 million, according to the
legislative Fiscal Bureau. The majority of that, $19.7 million, was
spent by the university.
In addition to the university not
submitting all of its expenses, there were other holes in the report
reviewed by AP.
Doyle's administration did not
request travel information from a handful of agencies, including the
state court system, the Legislature, the Wisconsin Housing and
Economic Development Authority, or either the governor or lieutenant
governor's office.
Those were not considered state
agencies for the purposes of this report, said Department of
Administration spokeswoman Linda Barth.
Doyle's administration isn't
questioning any state agency about any of the travel or asking that
expenses be justified. The report was requested just to get a sense
of what type of travel was taking place, Barth said Tuesday.
"Each state agency is
responsible for the decisions they make on employee travel,"
she said. "They'll continue to make those decisions. ... We
feel they're making the best decisions they can."
The amount spent on travel is
significant, said John Murray, spokesman for Assembly Speaker Mike
Huebsch, R-West Salem.
"We would hope these agencies
are very closely scrutinizing this travel to ensure that it is
critical to the operation of state government," Murray said.
Sen. Robert Cowles, R-Green Bay, said
cutting out travel shouldn't be hard.
"This is the kind of stuff I
call low-hanging fruit. These are the easy cuts, the easy
reductions," Cowles said.
Huebsch enacted a ban on out-of-state
travel for members of the state Assembly and their staffs effective
Feb. 11. There is no ban on travel in the Senate. A preliminary
review of records shows that there were at least seven trips
approved for senators and their staff members in the first three
months of the year where reimbursement from state money was
requested. The exact cost of the trips, to a variety of conferences,
was not immediately available.
State agencies spent money on trips
at the same time that Doyle's administration, along with legislative
leaders, are trying to solve a $527 million budget shortfall.
When it became obvious that the
weakening economy was resulting in the state not collecting enough
in taxes to cover its expenses, Morgan on Jan. 24 ordered agencies
to "place strict limitations on the use of out-of-state
travel."
Seeking travel restriction during
tight budget times is a popular public relations move but it does
little to solve the problem, said Todd Berry, president of the
nonpartisan Wisconsin Taxpayers Alliance.
"It's frustrating that the
out-of-state travel will get more political and press and citizen
attention than the fact that we have known since January that we
have a budget problem and we have done nothing major to address
it," Berry said.
Counting only trips that were paid
for out of the state's pocket, $917,152 was spent on 371 trips
between January and March, based on the AP review.
After the university, the agency that
spent the most on travel after that was the state Investment Board
at $104,775. The board's executive director defended the travel —
which included trips to Madrid, Munich, London, Tokyo and Dublin —
as necessary to fulfill the board's responsibility of managing the
state's investments.
"Travel is typically associated
with due-diligence prior to making an investment decision or
monitoring investments already made," Investment Board director
Keith Bozarth said in the letter to the state budget office.
Travel includes meeting with
prospective companies, visiting properties and fund managers and
attending company meetings, Bozarth said.