HACKENSACK,
N.J. — Spend a while at Pascack Hills High School in
Montvale, one of the first in New Jersey to hand every
student a laptop, and you’ll likely hear a teacher
tell students to "forty-five it."
That
means closing laptops halfway during a lesson — to a
45-degree angle — so they aren’t tempted to surf the
Internet, check email or shop for shoes. It’s one of
many techniques savvy teachers are adopting to keep the
attention of a generation easily sidetracked by an
unprecedented bounty of technology.
As
a growing number of schools let iPads, laptops and
cellphones enter the classroom, some teachers say they’re
shouldering a new role as electronics police. Teachers
warn constantly that abused devices will be confiscated.
Some continually roam behind the back row to see who is
watching what. And in a step that smacks of Big Brother,
some have programs that monitor all their students’
screens at the same time, and shut off the computer of
anyone goofing off.
In
interviews with a dozen teachers, many talked about the
tensions between embracing the digital era’s enormous
benefits for instruction and worrying about the
drawbacks. A survey released last month by the Pew
Research Center reflects these conflicting feelings: 77
percent of middle and high school teachers who have
advanced students said the Internet and digital search
tools have had a "mostly positive" impact on
their research projects. Even so, 64 percent said
digital technologies "do more to distract students
than to help them academically."
A
two-day conference starting today at River Dell Regional
High School will focus on how to make the best use of
laptops, tablets and other devices in class, and how to
keep kids engaged. About 140 educators from around the
country, including 60 from New Jersey, are expected to
attend.
It’s
organized by Project RED (for Revolutionizing Education
through Technology), whose leaders argue that using
computers properly can boost test scores, prevent
dropouts and even save money by cutting costs for
textbooks and copying. The group was founded by Intel,
the chip maker.
Ann
Flynn, director of education technology at the National
School Boards Association, said these tools should lead
to less lecturing by teachers and more hands-on projects
by students. Few districts, however, follow the rough
rule that about a third of the budget for new hardware
should go toward teacher training. "Teachers really
need to have a different set of skills and teach in a
different way," she said. "It’s not about
tossing the stuff in the classroom and expecting
magic."
Pascack
Hills High School, a high-achieving school in an
affluent district, issued individual laptops to students
nine years ago. Now it spends more than $1 million a
year to lease 2,503 Apple MacBooks for $413 per student,
and educators from as far as New Mexico, Nebraska and
Australia have visited to see them in action.
On
a recent morning, small groups of students clustered
around laptops as they used software to graph sound
waves made by various musical instruments.
Their
teacher, Brendan Field, said laptops enabled them to
tackle complex assignments they couldn’t otherwise
pursue but that the potential for distraction was a
"huge problem." He allowed each team to have
only one laptop open, and barred note-taking on laptops
in the belief that pencils and paper were more efficient
for math.
"It’s
a teacher’s responsibility to enforce good
habits" with technology, Field said. "They’re
tempted and will do what you let them do. I do try to
police it."
"It’s
a problem with adults at work, too," he added.
"It’s not kid-specific."
Some
teachers say they have to do more of a song and dance to
keep students engaged than in the past, and must work
harder to show how the material is relevant to their
lives.
"You
have to put on a show, and make sure there are multiple
activities each period," said Michelle Gaeta, a
Pascack Hills math teacher. "It was different with
my teachers. You knew you had to pay attention."
Despite
teachers’ efforts, many students readily acknowledge
sneaking off-topic peeks at their screens.
Michael
Vercellone, a senior and student government president at
Pascack Hills, said that although he loved his Science,
Ethics, Technology and Society course, and was
interested in a class discussion of Japanese doctors
torturing World War II prisoners for medical research,
he couldn’t help reading an irrelevant Wikipedia entry
on parasitic botflies.
"It
creeped me out. They get inside you," Vercellone
said. He dismissed any concern that he might miss
important academic points this way. "I can pay
attention and do two things at once. Most of us are good
at multitasking."
Many
teachers say the benefits of laptops in class
dramatically outweigh the costs. In an interdisciplinary
history and English class, teacher Owen Haveron spoke
about how juniors discussing "The Great
Gatsby" could quickly check online what it meant to
buy stock on margin. "That instant information can
really add to conversations," he said.
But
for some teachers, that immediate gratification has
hazards. The Pew Research Center’s survey, done in
conjunction with the College Board and National Writing
Project, found that 76 percent of 2,067 middle and high
school teachers "strongly agree" with the
assertion that search engines conditioned students to
expect to find information quickly and easily. For many
students, it said, research means Googling.
In
the survey, only 22 percent of teachers felt students
showed patience and determination in looking for
information. Pam Schwarz, a social studies teacher at
Pascack Hills, said it was hard to teach students
persistence and the value of intellectual struggle in
the face of Google’s ease.
"If
they don’t get an answer in a minute of searching they
get frustrated," she said. She requires that some
information on research papers come from "actual
books" so students have to hunt through the library
for different sources and multiple perspectives.
Most
teachers agree that students need more help navigating
the Internet wisely, said Kristen Purcell at Pew’s
Internet & American Life Project, who led focus
groups of teachers.
"Students
aren’t being taught the skills they need to make smart
choices, like assessing the quality of the information
they see online and being able to recognize bias,"
she said. Teachers reported that too often, these skills
were touched on in a piecemeal fashion, and left to
English teachers to fit in when possible. "The
education system has to figure out who will teach these
skills and when," Purcell said. "We’re
behind the ball in digital literacy."
Schools
around North Jersey have varying policies toward
devices. Some bar students from carrying cellphones
during the day, while others allow them only at certain
times or locations. Some teachers encourage using a
smart phone app for a graphing calculator, for example,
saving families the expense of buying one. Some schools
allow access to Twitter, while others block it, saying
it’s too addictive. Almost all bar Facebook.
Those
pushing for broad, innovative adoption of new devices
argue that students have to be nimble with them to
survive in an increasingly high-tech environment, and
must learn how to harness their own powers of
concentration.
"You
and I passed notes when we were in school," said
River Dell Superintendent Patrick Fletcher. "Kids
always had ways of distracting themselves."