Since its debut in
2007, the Flip video camera has turned millions of
people into filmmakers by providing a foolproof way to
shoot videos and upload them to the Web.
Last week, Flip maker Pure Digital
Technologies released two new versions — the Flip
Ultra ($150) and the Flip UltraHD ($200).
With these new additions, there are
now four Flip cameras to choose from — standard and
high-definition versions of the Flip Ultra and the Flip
Mino, which are sleeker, more expensive models.
I'm going to focus on the Flip UltraHD
and how it compares to the Flip MinoHD ($230), because I
suspect many consumers (myself included) will be
choosing between these two.
The Ultra weighs almost twice as much
as the Mino and is a lot bulkier. It still fits in your
pocket, but it's not nearly as sleek or stylish as the
Mino, which takes up so little space you may not even
realize it's in your bag. Unlike the Mino, which you can
buy in a variety of colors and even create your own
custom design, the Ultra is available only in black and
white.
But if you can get past the size and
aesthetic differences, there's a lot to like about the
Ultra. It can hold two hours of HD video — twice as
much as the Mino. It has a vibrant, 2-inch screen with a
higher resolution, which makes it easy to see what you
are shooting outside. The Mino HD has a 1.5-inch screen,
which sometimes makes it hard to frame your shots.
Another improvement is the Ultra's
power source, a sort of hybrid solution. The Mino has a
sealed internal battery that you charge on a computer,
meaning you never have to buy batteries. But if you run
out of juice and aren't near a computer or USB power
source, you're out of luck. The Ultra comes with a AA
battery pack, which you can charge with the USB port on
your computer and can also replace with regular AA
batteries in a pinch.
The Ultra has a port that lets you
connect it directly to your TV with an HDMI cable so you
can watch your videos in stunning HD quality.
Unfortunately, the cable isn't included, but you can buy
one from Pure Digital for $25. The Mino comes with
cables to connect it to your TV, but they are not HD
cables, so your video will play in standard definition.
The Mino features buttons that you tap
on lightly to operate while the Ultra has more
traditional buttons that require a hard push. Although
the Mino's buttons look much cooler, they can be
frustrating. The quality of the video was comparable,
although the Ultra's video and audio seemed a little
crisper. However, the Mino did a slightly better job
stabilizing shaky images.
Both cameras come with the Flip's
signature built-in software that runs on both PCs and
Macs and automatically installs when you pop out the USB
arm on the camera and connect it to the computer.
Yet another option for a compact, HD
camera is the Kodak Zx1 ($150), which is about the same
size as the Mino and also comes in lots of colors. The
key difference is that unlike the Flip cameras, the ZX1
has an SD card slot, so you can potentially record up to
10 hours of HD video, depending on the card's size.
The Kodak model has a rugged design
and rubberized ports, so it's resistant to rain, snow,
sand and dirt. But in order to make it so tough, Kodak
was not able to include a built-in USB arm to connect it
to a computer, so you have to use the included USB
cable. The software it comes with has a lot of features,
including the ability to upload to both YouTube and
Vimeo, but it's nowhere near as easy to use as the
on-board Flip software. It also works only on PCs
(though you can transfer files from the camera to a
Mac).
Like the Flip Ultra, it has an HDMI
port to connect the camera to your TV and it actually
comes with the cable. It also has a rechargeable AA
battery pack, but since there's no built-in USB arm, you
have to charge it with the supplied adapter. It can also
record in both standard and high definition.
The Zx1 has a lot more features than
the Flip, but part of what makes the Flip cameras so
popular are how simple and fun to use they are. With the
Zx1, you'll be checking the manual pretty often. But, if
you don't mind a learning curve and want more features
and functions, it's a good option.
Choosing between the Flip MinoHD and
the Flip UltraHD comes down to what's important to you.
If it's all about looks and size, then go for the Mino.
But if you can stand the extra bulk, and for $30 less
getting twice the storage space and a bigger, more
vibrant screen, the Ultra is a better choice.