SAN
FRANCISCO - The new version of Apple Inc.'s iPhone is
set to go on sale July 11, and the latest parlor game
among analysts involves guessing how much AT&T
Inc. is going to pay to subsidize the cost of the
device for consumers.
Those
estimates are high, ranging between a subsidy of $200
to $400 per phone, according to a MarketWatch survey
of analyst reports.
Apple
made waves earlier this month when it announced that a
new 3G version of the iPhone would go on sale at
prices starting at $199 - about half the current price
for the product.
To get
to that price, AT&T will be paying Apple what is
known as a carrier subsidy for each iPhone. The exact
amount of that subsidy has remained undisclosed by
both companies, though it has become the subject of a
broad range of speculation among those who follow
Apple and the mobile-phone marketplace.
Pacific
Crest analyst Andy Hargreaves predicts that Apple will
receive an initial subsidy of $350 for every iPhone
sold. Yair Reiner of Oppenheimer & Co. estimates
that AT&T is paying a $325 subsidy on every iPhone.
American Technology Research analyst Shaw Wu said that
the subsidy could range from between $200 and $400 per
unit.
"When
AT&T subsidizes the iPhone, they're essentially
making it cheaper for the consumer," said Shiv
Bakhshi, director of mobile-device research at IDC.
"Because it's an iconic phone, it invites that
customer into that network."
Neither
Apple nor AT&T will say how much of a subsidy is
involved with the iPhone. The first version of the
device did not come with a subsidy, though AT&T
paid Apple a monthly fee for every iPhone customer it
signed up. Apple ended up selling more than 6 million
units of the first version of the iPhone in less than
a year.
Subsidies
are not uncommon in the wireless market. For instance,
it is believed that wireless carriers paid Motorola
Inc. subsidies of as much as $200 for the Razr phone
when it first came out to keep the price down and
attract more buyers. The upshot is that by covering
part of the cost of a phone, carriers expect they can
make more money back over the length of a typical,
two-year service contract.
AT&T
currently is to price its iPhone plans at $39.99 a
month, charging an additional $30 a month for
unlimited 3G data. Business-data plans will cost $45 a
month.
Oppenheimer
analyst Reiner said that he based his $325 subsidy
figure on factors such as estimates for 4.5 million to
6.5 million iPhone sales in the second half of the
year, along with AT&T's forecasts that the 3G
iPhone will reduce its earnings by 10 cents to 12
cents a share in 2008 and 2009.
Reiner
estimates that the AT&T iPhone subsidy is about
$125 more than what is typically paid for high-end
wireless handsets in the United States.
"The
size of the subsidy reflects AT&T's faith in the
iPhone's ability to attract new subscribers and
increase average revenue (per user)," he wrote in
a research note. "But it also has positive
implications for (the) iPhone."
The
Oppenheimer analyst also said that the subsidy
"collapses the price umbrella that inspired
would-be iPhone killers," who counted on their
lower-priced phones to steal away business. Because of
this, Reiner estimates that Apple will be able to sell
15.2 million iPhones by the end of 2008 and 33.2
million in 2009.
In
addition to leading to higher iPhone sales for Apple,
Cowen & Co. analyst Arnie Berman said the
collapsing of that price umbrella could lead to a
"subsidy war" among wireless carriers, as
they seek to attract buyers.
AT&T's
subsidy decision, he added "reflects a land-grab
mentality" that will play out as other wireless
carriers expand their lines of smart phones.