When Dan Goggin started his line
of greeting cards, featuring a wisecracking nun, little did he
know that several years later his character would evolve into
"Nunsense," the second-longest-running off-Broadway
musical.
Twenty-six years after its debut, his quintet of nuns from
Hoboken, trying to fund the burial of four nuns presently
residing in their freezer, is still entertaining audiences
around the world.
Instead of the traditional bake sale or arts and crafts
fair, these five nuns decide to put on a show to raise money,
using their own singing and dancing skills as fodder for
donations.
Instead of the usual stereotypic nun figures - either
silly, childish creatures or harsh, cruel ones - Goggin has
created five individual human beings from very different
backgrounds. They are very different personalities who chose
to become nuns for very different reasons. This in itself is a
big improvement over most comedies or dramas featuring nuns.
When the story starts, we learn that Sister Julia, their
nun chef, has unwittingly poisoned 50 of their fellow nuns,
and the remaining five who survived the ordeal could only
afford to bury 46 of them. The remaining four await burial
until sufficient funds have been raised.
Mother Superior (Sister Regina), Mistress of Novices
(Sister Hubert), Novice (Sister Leo), the nun who forgot her
name (Sister Amnesia) and the gym teacher (Sister Robert Ann)
comprise the remaining brave souls, determined to carry on
with their duties.
Each character contributes something unique to the
performance. Sister Regina tries to exert control over the
whole venture, but is hilariously compromised when she
accidentally sniffs a substance which Sister Robert Ann
discovered in one of her student’s lockers. Sister Hubert
competes for power with Mother Superior.
Sister Leo, the youngest member of the house, still has a
longing to be a dancer, and Sister Robert Ann, the
street-smart one from Brooklyn, just wants to be on stage in
any capacity. Poor Sister Amnesia, who just wants to remember
who she is, amuses us with her jokes and her operatic voice.
Each character can belt out a good solo, but their ensemble
numbers are among the best. "Growing up Catholic"
was especially beautiful. Their little foray into Gregorian
Chant was very evocative of another era when Latin was
"in" and classical motifs reigned.
All five actors deserve mention: Bria Cloyd, the elegant
novice mistress; Lori Nappe, the dreamy novice; Antoinette
Stikl, the formidable mother superior; Emily Wacher Schultz,
the precious amnesiac; and Cat Zimmerman, the somewhat brazen
narcissist longing for a spotlight.
Additionally, Bryan Myers, who served as the musical
director and accompanist, and Diana Alioto,
director-choreographer, must be credited with the success of
the whole.
Those of us who attended Catholic schools will especially
enjoy this somewhat irreverent but affectionate reunion with
the nuns of our youth.
Those who didn’t will relish it for other reasons of
their own. From what I sensed from the audience, everyone on
stage and off was having a very good time. In fact, this may
have been the "whoopiest" audience I’ve ever
observed in Sunset Playhouse.
For those who love musicals, this is the second out of
three musical being offered by the Sunset Playhouse this year.