gmtoday_small.gif


Skylight's 'Sing Me a Story' filled with classic gems

By JULIE McHALE - TimeOut Theater Critic

May 9, 2013

 
MILWAUKEE - In case you thought the Skylight Music Theatre’s “Sing Me a Story” with Jack Forbes Wilson and Kay Steifel was just going to consist of a couple hours of melodic duets, which would have been fine, knowing the reputation of these two musicians, you would have been wrong. It is so much more than that.

The stage is set with a number of pianos and some other theatrical paraphernalia, thanks to the ingenuity of Lisa Schlenker, and we are off on a journey through musical history with a pair of pros at the helm. What a variety of standards and not-so-standards they have gathered and arranged, all delivered with artistry and feeling and many with some comedic shtick to boot.

I have seen both of these actors perform before - Wilson in “Two Pianos and Four Hands,” “Liberace” and “It’s a Wonderful Life,” and Steifel in “It’s a Grand Night for Singing” and “The Sound of Music.”  I’ve even heard them perform together at Stackner and Sunset, but this is an elaborate production, which must have been several years in the making, and the title song “Sing Me a Story” was written by Wilson.

With a few swift costume changes, they create various characters as they flit about the stage with ease and purpose, making everything look easy. Wilson, a master pianist, enhances every tune with his arrangements. He attacks the keys with zest, using his whole body to convey sincere enthusiasm.

Steifel displays a comic flair I’ve never seen before. There is a palpable chemistry between them, perhaps because they’ve worked together so many times and have put this show together themselves with the help of director Ray Jivoff, a man who always adds punch to every situation.

The repertory consists of several tunes from musicals such as Sondheim’s  “Getting Married Today”  and “The Little Things You Do Together” from “Company,” “Do You Love Me” from “Fiddler on the Roof,” and “Surrey with the Fringe on Top” from “Oklahoma” as a satisfying bonus at the end. They can take an old favorite and make it sound familiar and fresh simultaneously. Each number is a polished gem.

Alan Sherman makes the list with his famous Camp Grenada tunes. Wilson even resurrects a moving number from the one and only Broadway show written by Sherman, and though the show bombed, this song, “Did I Ever Really Live” deserves to be showcased.

Some of the novel numbers include “Double Yodel,” “Renoir, Degas and Toulouse,” “Complete Works of Shakespeare,” and “It’s Nice to Have a Walk in the Rain.” All were delivered with vigor and humor.

The two-hour show buzzed by quickly as we hoped it would never stop. At one point Wilson remarked that they were getting too old for this (some of the arrangements were quite physically demanding), and I thought, “You’re too good to stop. Keep singing us many more stories and telling us many more songs. We’ll be watching and listening and loving it.”

“Sing Me a Story” runs through May 19 in the Studio Theatre in the Broadway Theatre Center, 158 N. Broadway, Milwaukee. Call 414-291-7800 or visit www.skylightmusictheatre.org